Tuesday, November 03, 2026

2026/151: Once Was Willem — M R Carey

For the most part when we think on the past it’s not understanding that we’re looking for, but only the reassurance that we were in the right course all along. If understanding means touching on a sore place, we will go a different way. [p. 179]

Set in the fiefdom of Pennick during the Anarchy of the twelfth century, this is the story of a boy who died, and what he did afterwards. Willem was the son of loving parents: when he was taken by a fever, they approached a sorcerer, Cain Caradoc, to resurrect him. Unfortunately, Once-Was-Willem was resurrected as a protean monster. His parents, and the other folk of Cosham, reject him, and he lives wild in the woods. Once-Was-Willem does have friends, though: Peter Floodfoot, a water spirit, and Kel and Anna, sibling ulfeðnar (Kel shapeshifts to a bear, Anna to whatever she wishes) who came to England with Sweyn Astridsson a century ago.

Serbian bandit lord Maglan Horvath kills the local baron and takes his place. He becomes the puppet of Cain Caradoc, who sacrifices a girl from Cosham to gain more power from what's buried beneath the keep. The villagers, fearing for their children, approach Once-Was-Willem, who -- after considerable friction -- agrees to help them oppose Caradoc. He brings his friends: Peter, Kel and Anna. And there's the ghost of the sacrificed Betheli, and the ghost of a witch burnt by the folk of Cosham, and the terrifying Unsung Jill, who haunts the lonely places... Seven against Cain Caradoc, and a broader cosmology gradually revealed.

Carey's language is simple but evocative, peppered with archaic words (shent, meinie), and he's good at fleshing out even the minor characters. There are elements of folk horror as well as Caradoc's black magic, and a strong sense of the prevailing lawlessness and perils of the period. Once-Was-Willem is a fascinating and sympathetic narrator, often wryly witty. And in the end, kindness and loyalty win out against 'the cruelty and arbitrary will of those with great power and meagre conscience': a tale for our time.

I Will Tell You Seven -- Carey's original short story.

Read because: a Lockdown Book Club choice. I've enjoyed other novels by Carey, too.

No comments:

Post a Comment