We are not, in fact, victims of a great pre-written fate. Time -- all of it, all of human history -- is a great big messy conflagration of connectivity, of people making choices and choosing outcomes and all of it just tangling together until what could be coalesces into what is -- but still, people choose. [loc. 4553]
Time travellers exist. Often (always?) there is something indefinite about their birth: Cal, our protagonist, was born, a medieval peasant, 'in a moment of temporal uncertainty', to a mother 'pregnant/not pregnant from an affair with a man who had/had not passed by'.
Cal is indeterminate in other ways, too: sometimes male, sometimes female. They have a refreshingly cavalier approach to time travel (another time traveller is able to track them down via a cache of discarded asthma inhalers in a 17th-century manor house) and know how to close a rift in time by using an amaranthine, best described as a chronological paradox. And they, like all time travellers, are wary of the ghosts and witches ('fathomless creatures of unlived realities') that threaten those who move through time -- and, perhaps, threaten time itself.
The plot of As We Fall Through Time loops and layers confusingly, but at its heart is a love story (Cal falls in love with a French soldier named Olivier in 1789), a murder mystery (an archivist named Fadimatu causes a major paradox by encountering her own corpse in the Museum of the Unmasked Conspiracy), and a quixotic attempt by a time traveller named Bede to fix the climate catastrophe. The ways in which these three plots knot together is a twisty adventure, told by a mysterious first-person narrator in a resolutely non-linear sequence. It's the literary equivalent of a jigsaw puzzle, if the jigsaw puzzle sometimes made you laugh with delight at a new connection or a plot twist. And it was just as good on second reading: I found whole new angles of plot opening up.
Read because: Claire North has become one of my favourite authors -- from the 'Songs of Penelope' trilogy to the awesome Slow Gods. Obviously I read this as soon as it landed on my Kindle....
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the advance review copy, in exchange for this full honest review. UK Publication Date is 13th October 2026.






































