I knew, suddenly, why the Dragon took a girl from the valley. ... We were of the valley. Born in the valley, of families planted too deep to leave even when they knew their daughter might be taken; raised in the valley, drinking of whatever power also fed the Wood. [loc. 4176]
Agnieszka, seventeen, is certain that her friend Kasia will be chosen by the sorcerer known as the Dragon: will spend ten years in his stone tower, and will afterwards leave the valley where they've grown up. Agnieszka -- who is clumsy, ungainly, prone to dishevelment -- is extremely surprised to be chosen instead.
But it turns out that she's a witch: and though her powers are quite unlike the Dragon's, he's obliged to teach her... though not to be kind or patient with her. Most of what Agnieszka learns is from an ancient spellbook written by a legendary witch. (The Dragon tries to convince her that the spells are nonsense, since he'd never been able to get them to work.)
I first read this in 2015 (my original review) and had forgotten much of the plot. This time round I noticed that almost all of the major characters -- Agnieszka, Kasia, Queen Hanna, the sorceress Alosha, the forest queen -- are female; that each magic-user has a different style of magic (Agnieszka's is often described as fluid or wandering, the Dragon's is crisp and precise); that Agnieszka re-roots herself in village life, unlike all the girls before her.
The depiction of Agnieszka and Kasia's friendship was a delight -- including the nasty pettinesses that creep into even the best of friendships. The book club discussion also focussed on the romance: the age gap felt insignificant beside the inherent power dynamic of the teacher-student relationship. I'm glad to have revisited this, but it's not my favourite of Novik's novels -- though I now have a strong urge to reread the Scholomance books...
Read because: book club selection.






