This is not a work of military history, although the narrative heart is built around a series of military campaigns. Rather it is the story of an ancient struggle that was fought over many different kinds of battlefield, and with many different weapons. This conquest, fought in so many dimensions, has left all kinds of traces – not just in historians’ ink but in earth and bones and blood. [Introduction]
As per the introduction (quoted above) Addis doesn't just focus on the military aspects of the Roman occupation of Britain. True, he starts with Julius Caesar landing at Pevensey -- but he immediately questions the account, because it is Caesar's own. That first chapter, about Roman accounts of Britain and about their maps, is entitled 'Ink'. Next comes 'Earth', which explores the prehistory of the British Isles: mammoths, Doggerland, archaeoDNA (intersecting pleasingly with another book I was reading at the same time, Proto by Laura Spinney, about Proto Indo European). Then comes 'Gold', a potted history of coinage, trade and wealth inequality.
The second part of the book, 'Taking Hold (AD 43 - AD 83)', has chapters entitled 'Bone' (a history of human violence: I learnt that the earliest known victim of a projectile weapon died 30,000 years ago); 'Blood' (battles, sacrificial rituals, Boudicca); 'Water' (British religious practises); 'Fire' (Roman religious practises); and 'Peace' (subduing the British, Agricola in Scotland). And the final section of the book, 'Clinging On (AD 83 - The Present Day)', includes a great deal about Roman infrastructure and building, but also about life in Roman Britain; the ruins the Romans left behind, and the turmoil of the so-called Dark Ages; and the ways in which the Roman occupation influenced later British history. Colonial administrators raised on Tacitus and Virgil had a definite sense of what made an empire, and Rome was its model.
This was a captivating read: I listened to the audiobook (read by the author) and will also be acquiring a text version so I can reread some sections and see the maps and footnotes. I especially appreciated Addis's contextualisation: he doesn't limit his account to the British Isles, but shows how events elsewhere in the Roman Empire affected military and domestic matters in Britain. The wealth of evidence, from archaeological excavations to ancient DNA, also provided a solid foundation for this account -- and Addis is at pains to stress that this evidence supports, rather than proves, various theories and ideas about the distant past.
Addis is also a very readable writer. His descriptions of location -- both as they might have been in the past, and as they are now -- are evocative and sometimes poetic. He has an eye for humanising detail (dinner parties at Vindolanda, Tacitus' account of Caratacus in chains before the Emperor Claudius) and a comprehensive knowledge of his subject. I wish more 'history' books were like this.
Read because: this review in New Scientist sparked my curiosity: I've been interested in Roman Britain for as long as I can remember, starting with Rosemary Sutcliff's novels.






