2026/132: Other Minds — Peter Godfrey-Smith

If we can make contact with cephalopods as sentient beings, it is not because of a shared history, not because of kinship, but because evolution built minds twice over. This is probably the closest we will come to meeting an intelligent alien. [loc. 131]

Sometimes lyrical, sometimes very technical, this is an account of octopus intelligence -- its origins, its manifestations, its implications -- by a philosopher with a scientific background and a passion for scuba-diving.

The common ancestor of humans and cephalopods has been dated to 750 million years ago (more than twice the separation between humans and any other vertebrate). If octopuses are intelligent, then evolution came up with intelligence not once but twice. Octopuses, and closely-related cephalopods such as cuttlefish and perhaps squid, show intelligent behaviour in a variety of ways: they play, they manipulate their environment, they communicate. Their brains are very different from vertebrate brains, being more distributed. And they have very short lifespans, which seems tragic.

I enjoyed Godfrey-Smith's accounts of his encounters with octopuses and giant cuttlefish, including being led by the hand by one curious individual. The philosophical elements -- what is it like to be an octopus? echoing Nagel's 'What Is It Like to Be a Bat?, which was a set text when I was a philosophy undergraduate -- were less interesting to me, but I read the scientific studies with fascination... while cringing at some of the experiments performed on sentient creatures. ('Sentience comes before consciousness,' writes Godfrey-Smith: and he also makes a good case for consciousness.) A truly fascinating read, with compassion and empathy as much as science and philosophy.

Narrated by Peter Noble, whose enthusiasm and warmth kept me listening through the more theoretical sections.

Read because: I've owned the Kindle version since, er, May 2018: the audio version (from the library) was easier to get into, and then I alternated between text and audio. I have wanted to read it, but I think was put off by the dense philosophising -- though, on initial reading way back when, I got far enough to make me swear off eating octopus.

2026/131: What Happened That Night — Nicci French

...while I’ve been in my own particular hell since Leo’s murder, you don’t seem to have lived the lives you longed for when we were young and full of promise. [loc. 1388]

Tyler Green has spent nearly 29 years in prison, found guilty of the murder of his friend Leo Bauer at a post-exam house party at university. He claims he is innocent, and asks a friend to organise a reunion of the guests at that house party. They haven't kept in touch, and all have changed a great deal -- Tyler's girlfriend, Ali, is now married to Will; Beatrice, who's hosting the reunion, is a KC married to an MP; Marco's musical career has descended into pub gigs. And by the end of the (horrible) dinner party, there's another death.

That's the first third of the book. Then we get to meet DI Maud O'Connor and her DS Carrie Kessler, investigating the death. Maud's bosses are convinced Tyler has struck again, but she's not so sure.

I spotted the murderer at 41%.

Good on toxic interpersonal relationships, the ways in which people change between university and middle age, and the dangers of police prejudice. I would have liked more of Tyler's viewpoint, and I felt very sorry for Conrad Bauer, crusading for penalties after the death of his son. There was some interestingly subtle clues that led Maud to her conclusion. But really, very few likeable characters and unexceptional prose -- and a couple of jarring moments, such as Maud making a veiled comment about the personal life of one of the characters, and a throwaway, improbable line intended to distract attention from the actual murderer.

Read because: one of my challenge prompts was 'two authors, one pseudonym': Nicci French ('the pseudonym of English husband-and-wife team Nicci Gerrard and Sean French ') seemed a popular choice, and I'd never read any of their books.

2026/130: Uprooted — Naomi Novik

I knew, suddenly, why the Dragon took a girl from the valley. ... We were of the valley. Born in the valley, of families planted too deep to leave even when they knew their daughter might be taken; raised in the valley, drinking of whatever power also fed the Wood. [loc. 4176]

Agnieszka, seventeen, is certain that her friend Kasia will be chosen by the sorcerer known as the Dragon: will spend ten years in his stone tower, and will afterwards leave the valley where they've grown up. Agnieszka -- who is clumsy, ungainly, prone to dishevelment -- is extremely surprised to be chosen instead. 

But it turns out that she's a witch: and though her powers are quite unlike the Dragon's, he's obliged to teach her... though not to be kind or patient with her. Most of what Agnieszka learns is from an ancient spellbook written by a legendary witch. (The Dragon tries to convince her that the spells are nonsense, since he'd never been able to get them to work.)

I first read this in 2015 (my original review) and had forgotten much of the plot. This time round I noticed that almost all of the major characters -- Agnieszka, Kasia, Queen Hanna, the sorceress Alosha, the forest queen -- are female; that each magic-user has a different style of magic (Agnieszka's is often described as fluid or wandering, the Dragon's is crisp and precise); that Agnieszka re-roots herself in village life, unlike all the girls before her. 

The depiction of Agnieszka and Kasia's friendship was a delight -- including the nasty pettinesses that creep into even the best of friendships. The book club discussion also focussed on the romance: the age gap felt insignificant beside the inherent power dynamic of the teacher-student relationship. I'm glad to have revisited this, but it's not my favourite of Novik's novels -- though I now have a strong urge to reread the Scholomance books...

Read because: book club selection.

2026/129: Dionysus in Wisconsin — E H Lupton

"...since you met him you keep getting attacked by demons.”
“Twice!” Sam said. “It’s happened twice.”
“It’s been two weeks!”
Harry was looking back and forth between them nervously. “Ellen, every relationship has trade-offs.”[p. 193]

Audiobook of a novel I enjoyed very much last winter (original review from January). Dionysus in Wisconsin is set in Madison in 1969, in a reality where magic works and ghosts walk. Ulysses Lenkov is a 'human lightning rod', a magician who can attract and talk to spirits (but can't decide a subject for his dissertation). Sam Sterling is a mild-mannered archivist who's moved back to Madison to be near his family, who he doesn't especially like. Warned by a fellow magic-user that something big is coming -- something connected with the god Dionysus -- Ulysses seeks out Sam and discovers that his first name happens to be Dionysus ... and that there's a strong mutual attraction between them.

Narrated by Scott Paige, who gives each character a distinct voice (and manages a very spooky ghost-Abi at one point). I really liked the loucheness of his Ulysses, and the way that Sam and Ulysses' voices changed over the course of the book. Ulysses is much more fun after he's lightened up a bit and allowed himself to be emotionally involved with Sam, and Sam's dilemma. And Sam sounds much more confident by the end of the novel.

Read because: I noticed that E H Lupton was offering free review copies, and leapt at the chance. And now, of course, I want to reread the rest of the series...

Thanks to the author for the advance review copy, in exchange for this full honest review. The audiobook is available now.

2026/128: The CIA Book Club — Charlie English

"A book was like fresh air. They allowed us to survive and not go mad.”

During the 1980s, the Solidarity movement in Poland (expanded from the original Solidarity union) was the main opposition to the Soviet-backed Communist regime. Even before martial law was declared in 1981, the CIA were quietly funding the import, publication and distribution of subversive literature, from Solzhenitsyn's Gulag Archipelago to Orwell's 1984 ... as well as fashion magazines, the Guardian Weekly, and novels by Vonnegut and Le Carre. America also funded underground printing initiatives, such as Mazovia Weekly and Kultura.

English's book is well-researched yet reads like a thriller, with vivid characters (ex-pat Jerzy Giedroyc in Paris, whose CIA codename was QRBERETTA; Mirosław Chojecki, self-appointed Minister for Smuggling; Helena Łuczywo, editor of Mazovia Weekly, who relied on the innate chauvinism of the secret police to keep her and her mostly-female team safe) and a compelling account of the key events of the period, from the founding of the Solidarity union to the election of Lech Wałęsa as President in 1990.

I remember some (though not all) of the major events covered in this book, but very much from the perspective of a teenager with little interest in politics and less understanding of what it might be like to live under an oppressive regime. I certainly wouldn't, then or now, have associated the CIA with such a hands-off, benevolent approach to undermining communism! (It's harder to imagine it happening in 2026.) And I found English's account of underground activism uplifting, even inspiring: people's time, money, effort, even lives, dedicated to a greater cause.

Narrated by James Parsons, who (as far as I can tell) pronounced Polish names correctly and clearly, and highlighted the occasional black humour of the book.

Read because: I bought the ebook when it was on offer -- I think it was at a time when my interest in the Cold War peaked -- but didn't get around to it until I noticed that the library had the audiobook. I combined the two, which worked very nicely.

2026/127: Yield Under Great Persuasion — Alexandra Rowland

...maybe finally he’d be a different person, someone he liked more than the person he was now. Someone who could let sweetness and softness happen to him without his throat closing up in fear and suspicion. Someone who could be loved. [p. 163]

Tam Brocken runs a tea shop in a village. He's lonely, if you discount -- as he does -- the more-or-less weekly occasions on which he has sex with Lord Lyford. He always leaves hastily, and it's just sex, so that's all right -- even if Lyford (who he's hated since childhood) keeps flirting with him. And then Tam and Lyford are assigned to run the matchmaking tent at the village festival. Together.

Then Tam, trying to escape the village gossips, meets the goddess Angarat on the road, and she imparts a few home truths ... including that Tam is stuck in a rut of his own devising, and that he should keep an open mind about Lyford, and give him a chance to redeem himself.

This is a story about second chances, divine favor, and trying to be a better person. It's a sweet story, though Tam is often far from sweet: and it's also a rural idyll, with gods walking the world and interacting with humans, and with a really strong sense of Lyford and Tam's love for the land. A gentle and life-affirming novel that's often very funny and (usually at other points) very steamy.

Read because: wishlist hit, plus I'd just finished a book by Rowland's fellow Serpent Freya Marske. Though the two are very different writers, there's a commonality of timbre. I also felt that the explicit sex scenes qualified this as a fill for the 'erotic fantasy' prompt on a book challenge. Also, 'set at harvest time'.

2026/126: Bodies of Magic — Freya Marske

Perhaps a body was all you ever were.
Perhaps a body was the least of what you were.
They were days away from becoming a fully-fledged healer and they still didn't know which was true. Or if both were, somehow. [loc. 2776]

Five medical students at the Academie of the Grand Duchy of Sieuxerr are about to begin their final exam -- a week-long trial of five medical cases, which the five healers will have to work together to diagnose and perhaps treat. They will pass together, or fail together. And this particular exam group (randomly chosen, of course) comprises five very different individuals, each with secrets, each with complicated emotions towards the others. Moyna is the daughter of ambitious parents who moved to Sieuxerr so that Moyna could be trained in the healing arts, and serve her community. Alys is an aristocratic beauty with little magical aptitude. Estiene is the son of the Head Healer. Jehan comes from a working-class, single-parent family. Clement is non-binary, and the best friend of the most gifted student of their year, Ysabel Caudotte ... and Ysabel is found, dead, in their exam chamber on the first day of the exam.

She's not their case: they don't have to diagnose or treat. But each of the five has some connection to Ysabel, and each has secrets to keep, complications to manouevre, expectations and fears and hopes. As the week progresses, it's clear that Ysabel had been planning something: but what? And did it lead to her death?

The gradual fleshing-out of each of the five, as the novel rotates through their viewpoints, is brilliantly and effectively achieved. Each begins the week distrusting one or more of their fellow candidates: each ends the week with a better understanding of the others, and of their own skills and weaknesses. The medical cases are interesting, too, and the author's medical background is evident in the details of diagnostic techniques.

Marske's worldbuilding is understated but sound: I liked the little details of Sieuxerr, from the lingering horrors of a terrible pandemic (the serrage) to the almond-paste 'sweetmice' that are eaten to celebrate Mathe's feast; from the artificers' strikes to the bestselling popular novels about Healer Chambeley. The themes of class, of institutional corruption, and of medical diagnosis are thoroughly explored, but there's also room for romance(s) as well as the core murder mystery. I liked this a great deal.

Read because: I checked Netgalley as soon as I heard that Marske had a new novel on the way: I discovered her via the Be the Serpent podcast, and have very much enjoyed her other work.

Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the advance review copy, in exchange for this full honest review. UK Publication Date is 17th September 2026.